|
  Compensation for injury
and death
The amount paid as compensation (Rs 715 crores, $450 million) has multiplied as a result
of the increase in the value of the dollar and the accruing interest. Rs 910 crores ($570
million) has been paid to 400,000 claimants (four lakh) and a balance of about Rs 1100
crores ($690 million) remains to be distributed.
Problems with distribution
The procedures for compensation disbursement have been tortuous and thoroughly
unjust. More than 90% of the claimants have been paid less than Rs 25,000
($595) as compensation for personal injuries, out of which nearly Rs 10,000
($238) has been routinely deducted against interim monetary relief paid
by the government from 1990. The remaining money does not even cover half
the recent medical expenses incurred by the claimants let alone provide
for the future.
(Exchange rates are calculated according to figures given below. See
table. With 90% of the injured being paid well under the figures given
above, we make an average - which errs on the generous side - of $500
compensation for personal injury. Over the nearly 18 years that have now
elapsed, this works out at about 7 cents a day - even in the poor bastis
of Bhopal this is perhaps enough for a cup of tea.)
A large number of the young people affected by the gas have no documents to show that
they are victims and so will not qualify for the benefits that may be offered.
"Reduction" of claims
Of the 14,775 death claims adjudicated, 65% have been rejected or converted into personal
injury cases. Judges at the claim courts are ignorant of the medical consequences of toxic
exposure and the administration of compensation is riddled with corruption so that the
claimants' inability to pay bribes often results in denial of compensation.
In response to an official announcement for fresh registration of claims in December
1996, over 400,000 (4 lakh) claims have been filed - the majority of them by persons
residing outside the gas affected area, including elite neighborhoods. As a result,
genuine victims will be the ultimate losers in the disbursement of compensation.
Compensation figures
Approx exchange rate: 70 rupees = 1 UK Pound, 42 Rupees = 1 US Dollar.
| COMPLAINT |
AMOUNT IN RUPEES |
| A. Eyes |
|
| 1. Chronic conjunctivitis |
35,000 |
| 2. Cornial opacities |
50,000-55,000 |
| B. Respiratory diseases |
|
| 1. Abnormal P.F.T. |
40,000 |
| 1a. U.R.I. |
35,000 |
| 2. Chronic bronchitis |
35,000 |
| 3. Asthma |
45,000 |
| 4. Pleural effusion |
45,000 |
| 5. Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease/ chronic
obstructive airways disease |
50,000-55,000 |
| 5a. Interstitial fibrosis of the lungs |
40,000-50,000 |
| 6. Emphysema |
60,000-65,000 |
| 7. Bronchiactasis |
60,000-65,000 |
| 8. Alvyolytis |
60,000-65,000 |
| 9. Corpulmonale |
80,000-85,000 |
10. Pulmonary tuberculosis
i. unilateral infiltration
ii. bilateral infiltration
|
45,000-55,000
55,000-65,000 |
| C. Gastrointestinal tract |
|
| 1. Gastritis |
35,000 |
| 2. Peptic acid disease |
40,000 |
| 2a. Hyper acidity or recurrent digestive symptoms (RDS) |
35,000 |
| D. Musculo-skeletal system |
|
| 1. Myalgia |
35,000 |
| E. Psychosomatic diseases |
|
| 1. Anxiety |
35,000 |
| 2. Depression |
35,000 |
| F. B and D without any specified disease |
35,000 |
[Top] |