A shareholder resolution put forward by Amnesty International, Calvert Investments and other Dow Investors was blocked leading up to Dow’s Annual General Meeting. Amnesty’s press release is below, Calvert Invetment’s can be found here.
Amnesty International Reports: (WASHINGTON, D.C.) – As we near the 30th anniversary of the devastating gas leak from the Union Carbide plant in Bhopal, The Dow Chemical Company (Dow) is still choosing to ignore the toxic legacy of the disaster. In stark contrast, survivors and residents of Bhopal have no choice but to live with the tragedy on a daily basis; over 100,000 people still suffer from health problems due to exposure to the gas and there remain high levels of contaminants in soil at the former factory site and the local groundwater due to the plant’s prior operations.
Dow shareholders attending the company’s annual general meeting (AGM) in the U.S. tomorrow, will be denied a vital opportunity to understand the continuing impact of the Bhopal disaster.
Dow blocked Amnesty International and other investors from putting forward a shareholder resolution at the AGM, which called on Dow to face-up to the ongoing legacy of Bhopal. The resolution requested Dow to prepare a report for shareholders on the “financial, reputational and operational impacts…of…Bhopal…on Dow’s Indian and global business opportunities.”
The resolution underscored how Dow’s name has become inextricably linked with the Bhopal disaster since its acquisition of Union Carbide Corporation (UCC) in 2001. Dow is now the focus of legal and campaign actions by Bhopal survivors and the Indian government, which have adversely affected both its business and reputation. It is a defendant to two civil claims before the Indian courts. Most recently, Dow has been ordered to appear before the Bhopal criminal court on July 4, 2014, to explain why its 100% owned subsidiary, UCC, has repeatedly ignored summons to appear before the court in the ongoing criminal case concerning the disaster.
Dow stopped the resolution from being put to shareholders by taking advantage of a U.S. rule that permits listed companies to reject a shareholder resolution if “the company has already substantially implemented the proposal.” On that basis, Dow asked the U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC), the government agency responsible for regulating U.S.-listed companies, to confirm that it would not take action against Dow if it blocked the resolution from being put before shareholders. The SEC gave this confirmation .
Amnesty International is deeply disappointed by Dow’s decision to block the resolution. Dow has again failed to alter its longstanding position that it has no responsibility for Bhopal, which completely ignores the continuing human rights abuses in Bhopal and its adverse effect on Dow’s business and reputation .
Dow has recently reiterated this position, stating that it “[does] not believe that Bhopal…will have any financial, operational or reputational impact on Dow’s business opportunities in India or elsewhere in the world” and ” will continue to oppose efforts to implicate Dow in the Bhopal matter .”
Amnesty International strongly disagrees with Dow’s statement. Not only does Dow’s position affect its business and reputation in India but it also reflects its refusal to take seriously its responsibility to disclose these issues to its shareholders. Amnesty International believes that shareholders should be informed of corporate involvement in ongoing human rights abuse cases – shareholders should play an essential role in ensuring that companies respect human rights and take active steps to address their human rights impacts.
Amnesty International urges shareholders to request Dow to provide full disclosure of the ongoing human rights and environmental impacts of Bhopal, given its materiality to Dow’s Indian and global business opportunities.
Dow should acknowledge its responsibility towards survivors of the disaster and appear before the Indian criminal court on July 4, 2014 to explain why it has failed to ensure that UCC faces the charges against it.
Amnesty International is a Nobel Peace Prize-winning grassroots activist organization with more than 3 million members in more than 150 countries campaigning for human rights worldwide. The organization investigates and exposes abuses, educates and mobilizes the public, and works to protect people wherever justice, freedom, truth and dignity are denied.